Home   Logon   Mobile Site   Research and Commentary   About Us   Call 1.800.621.1675 or Email Us       Follow Us: 

Search by Ticker, Keyword or CUSIP       
 
 

Blog Home
   Brian Wesbury
Chief Economist
 
Click for Bio
Follow Brian on Twitter Follow Brian on LinkedIn View Videos on YouTube
   Bob Stein
Deputy Chief Economist
Click for Bio
Follow Bob on Twitter Follow Bob on LinkedIn View Videos on YouTube
 
  Dead Cat Bounce for Socialism
Posted Under: Europe • Monday Morning Outlook
The Social Welfare State is dying.  Like the Berlin Wall and the Iron Curtain, the cradle-to-grave social welfare experiment must eventually collapse.  A system of taxing work and profits, while subsidizing leisure, sloth, and retirement, must eventually fail.

The end of the Social Welfare State is painful for many, and it will not end quickly or quietly as the elections of this past weekend prove.  Francois Hollande, a Socialist, was elected president of France, while Greece saw a surge in votes for "anti-bailout" political parties in parliament.
 
These elections are described as blows against "austerity."  They are also seen as anti-German.  Germany resisted bailouts and pushed spending cuts.
 
In theory, a rejection of austerity could be a good thing.  Some people include tax hikes in the concept of austerity and avoiding tax hikes would be a good thing for Europe.  France has a top income tax rate of 45%, a wealth tax of 0.5% and a Value Added Tax (VAT) of 21.2%.  Greece has a top income tax rate of 45% and a VAT of 23%.  These burdensome tax rates hinder growth, investment and work effort and still don't cover all the spending.
 
To solve the deficit problem, Francois Hollande wants to raise France's top income tax rate to 75%.  Greece's "anti-bailout" parties, mostly on the left, also want higher taxes on the upscale, plus defense cuts.  The Greek military helps break up domestic riots, so this is a self-serving demand. 
 
So, in reality, French and Greek rejection of austerity does not mean policies that would enhance long term economic growth.  Instead, it means they want to temporarily pull the wool over their own eyes, resist the obvious need to reduce government spending, and just hope for the best.
 
This chapter of the French story will not end well.  The country has already gone much further along the road to socialism than the US, with general government spending equal to about 56% of GDP, very near the highest of any advanced or emerging market in the world.  Greece, at 49%, is not far behind.  Yet, voters are doubling down.
 
Markets already sense the problems this will cause.  The Euro is weaker and stock prices are down around the globe.  Many fear that pressure on the European Central Bank to buy more Euro debt and help avoid austerity will create inflation.  This is happening despite the fact that Hollande was a huge favorite to win and this should have been built into the market already.  It was the ease of victory, combined with the vote in Greece that made the day feel even more anti-market.
 
But even easy money would ultimately be a dead end, leading to higher interest rates and less capital investment.  Anyway, the Germans would never go along with a euro as weak and inflationary as many in Greece and France want.  And Germany has huge leverage: if the ECB gets too loose, only Germany could leave the euro, go back to its old currency, and not get hammered by financial markets.
 
In the end, this is a battle the socialists are simply not going to win.  Greece is too small to be convincing; France is about to show the world what doesn't work. 
 
With any luck, after dabbling in folly, France will reverse course quickly.  Maybe Hollande himself, not an unintelligent man, will realize the mistake of fighting the end of the social welfare state.  The citizens of Europe who think austerity is unnecessary are about to get a lesson in reality.  In the end the only way out is more capitalism.
 
And this brings us to our most important point.  Financial markets in the US moved abruptly to a "risk off" trade as these election results were finalized.  Stocks sold off and bonds rallied.  But those who think these elections will hurt the US are wrong.  The end of the social welfare state in Europe is a precursor for the US.  It's a Dead Cat Bounce for Socialism.

Click here for a PDF version.
Posted on Monday, May 7, 2012 @ 9:54 AM • Post Link Share: 
Print this post Printer Friendly

These posts were prepared by First Trust Advisors L.P., and reflect the current opinion of the authors. They are based upon sources and data believed to be accurate and reliable. Opinions and forward looking statements expressed are subject to change without notice. This information does not constitute a solicitation or an offer to buy or sell any security.
 
The information presented is not intended to constitute an investment recommendation for, or advice to, any specific person. By providing this information, First Trust is not undertaking to give advice in any fiduciary capacity within the meaning of ERISA, the Internal Revenue Code or any other regulatory framework. Financial professionals are responsible for evaluating investment risks independently and for exercising independent judgment in determining whether investments are appropriate for their clients.
First Trust Portfolios L.P.  Member SIPC and FINRA. (Form CRS)   •  First Trust Advisors L.P. (Form CRS)
Home |  Important Legal Information |  Privacy Policy |  California Privacy Policy |  Business Continuity Plan |  FINRA BrokerCheck
Copyright © 2020 All rights reserved.