Existing Home Sales Declined 1.7% in November


Implications:  Existing home sales gave up ground in November following a rebound in October, demonstrating the volatile nature of the growth in sales since the upward trend began early this year.  Putting aside the headline number, the real piece of worrying news in today's report was that the inventory of existing homes listed for sale has now fallen year-over-year (the best measure for inventories given the seasonality of the data) since June, following ten straight months of gains.  This is concerning because it represents a consistent reversal in the upward trend in listings earlier this year and will likely be a headwind for future sales.  Keep in mind, the primary culprit behind the weak existing home market in 2018 was lack of supply.  It's also important to note that the months' supply of existing homes – how long it would take to sell the current inventory at the most recent sales pace – was only 3.7 months in November and has now stood below 5.0 (the level the National Association of Realtors considers tight) since late 2015.  With demand so strong that 45% of homes sold in November were on the market for less than a month, inventories remain crucial to sales activity going forward.  The good news is that builders are beginning to respond, with both permits for new residential construction and the total number of housing units under construction rising consistently over the past several months to post-recession highs.  As these properties are finished, and people trade up or down to a new home, more inventory of existing homes will become available.  More construction will be doubly important for properties worth $250k or less, where sales have sputtered.  What this means is that the "mix" of homes sold is more and more tilted toward the higher end.  When you add in mortgage rates that have fallen roughly 110 basis points since the peak in November 2018, it's no surprise that the year-over-year growth in median prices has begun to reaccelerate and is now up 5.4% in the past year versus its low of just 3.3% in December.  In other news this morning, initial jobless claims fell 18,000 last week to 234,000, while continuing claims rose 51,000 to 1.722 million.  The recent increase in claims from prior lows likely reflects volatility that often occurs between Thanksgiving and MLK Day and should not cause concern.  Finally, on the manufacturing front this morning, the Philly Fed Index, a measure of East Coast factory sentiment, fell unexpectedly to +0.3 in December from +10.4 in November.  Despite the weak headline, the forward-looking components of the report were strong with new orders, hiring expectations, and capital expenditure plans all rising. Its also important to note that the survey period for December fell before the announcement of a Phase 1 trade deal with China, which should boost sentiment going forward.  

Click here for PDF version

Posted on Thursday, December 19, 2019 @ 12:15 PM

These posts were prepared by First Trust Advisors L.P., and reflect the current opinion of the authors. They are based upon sources and data believed to be accurate and reliable. Opinions and forward looking statements expressed are subject to change without notice. This information does not constitute a solicitation or an offer to buy or sell any security.